?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry Share Next Entry
Прохоровка
zmeygor
Историк Ben Wheatley, британец, опубликовал (точнее, написал; опубликовал журнал, позавчера) исследование архивных данных аэрофотосъёмки, сделанной Люфтваффе, области, в которой происходила одна из самых жесточайших танковых битв истории, известной как "битва под Прохоровкой".

A visual examination of the battle of Prokhorovka

In conclusion, given our knowledge of the relative losses incurred by both sides and the locations of the tanks on the battlefield, it is clear that the photographic evidence contained in this article support Frieser’s description of the battle – i.e. that the Soviets suffered a major defeat and incurred vast numbers of written off tanks in the process. The location of the mass destruction of the 29th Tank Corps armour is clear to see with 32nd & 31st Tank Brigades demise in (or near to) the anti-tank ditch and 25th Tank Brigade’s defeat between the railway embankment, Stalinsk state farm and the Storozhevoye Woods also being clearly visible in the photographs provided. Regarding the halting of 18th Tank Corps – we can see from the photographs available to us that the Soviet attempt to outflank the Leibstandarte was also met with a major defeat. The demise of the 170th & 181st Tank Brigades is clearly highlighted behind the left flank of the anti-tank ditch and the 2nd SS Panzergrenadier Regiment’s position. The defeat of 181st Tank Brigade’s subsequent effort to advance up from the ribbon village of Andreyevka is also depicted. The fact that only four Tiger tanks repelled both of these armoured advances is testament to the tanks’ prowess at that stage of the war.

This article has therefore verified the demise of the majority of the attacking components of the 5th Guards Tank Army during the battle of Prokhorovka on 12 July 1943. As has been shown above, the level of detailed information now available to us means it is entirely possible that individual lost German tanks can be located on the battlefield photographs amongst the mass of Soviet tank losses. It is remarkable that the historiography of the battle has evolved so radically over the last 20–30 years from an era when it was believed the Germans had suffered a major war-defining defeat with the loss of as many as 400 tanks (including 70 Tigers), to one that recognizes (with respect) that a Soviet catastrophe took place and that this catastrophe can be visually verified. If the myth of Prokhorovka is still given any credence around the world then the photographs contained in this article will surely bring this myth to an end.


Это, пиздец, друзья мои.

Пиздец не только по тому, какой ценой нам далась эта победа. Это пиздец прежде всего потому, что данные по нашей истории мы опять узнаём из архивов других стран, проанализированных третьей стороной на чужом языке...

А наши архивы что? Да по прежнему - засекречены. Причём как молва говорит, недавно срок снова продлили, теперь уже аж до 2050 года.
Оригинал записи тут: https://arech.dreamwidth.org/91808.html. Коментить лучше там (OpenID работает), но можно пока и тут.